The Hidden Pain of Second Generation Immigrants: Breaking the Trauma Cycle
Something sits quietly in the hearts of second-generation immigrants—a pain rarely discussed [8]. Over 65 million people have left their homes due to conflict, with over 21 million being refugees, more than half of whom are children under 18 [11]. In North America., immigrant families and their children are growing [1], and many carry untold stories. We intimately understand the feeling of being caught between two worlds, the loneliness of not fitting in, and the questions about our identity [12]. These struggles impact our mental health in overwhelming ways.
Trauma can affect not just the individual but also travel through generations as intergenerational trauma [11]. This may manifest as PTSD symptoms in families, even if children did not experience the original events [8]. Understanding these patterns is where healing begins. We're here to navigate this together, discussing hidden struggles, especially the unseen guilt [12]. Most importantly, we aim to provide gentle guidance for breaking cycles of pain carried through families for too long. You're not alone, and there is a path forward.
What is intergenerational trauma?
Definition and origins
Sometimes pain travels in ways we don't expect. Researchers first noticed this when they saw children showing signs of deep distress even though they had never experienced trauma directly themselves. This discovery began with Holocaust survivors' children who struggled with severe mental health symptoms despite being born years after World War II ended [7]. What they found was intergenerational trauma—the way emotional wounds from one generation can quietly pass to the next, carrying forward the effects of oppression, poverty, and other painful experiences that parents and grandparents endured [12].
Since then, this understanding has grown to include many different communities. Children and grandchildren of people who survived the Holocaust, World War II, the Rwandan genocide, the Khmer Rouge, and other devastating events often experience higher rates of anxiety, depression, and PTSD than others [7]. Refugees, war veterans, and families affected by colonization all carry these invisible threads of pain that can reach across generations [12].
How trauma is passed down through generations
Trauma finds multiple ways to travel from parent to child. Our bodies actually change when we experience severe stress—something called epigenetic changes can alter how our genes work without changing the genes themselves [10]. When someone goes through trauma, their body might adapt in ways that can then be passed to their children [13].
Our families' journeys to new countries often involve profound losses that create lasting ripple effects. The experience of leaving everything behind, starting over in an unfamiliar place, and adapting to a completely different culture creates stress that touches every family member [4]. These experiences don't just disappear—they weave themselves into daily life and family relationships.
The way parents relate to their children also carries trauma forward. Those who have endured significant pain might find it harder to connect emotionally, show less patience, or communicate in ways that reflect their own stress and worry [7]. Children growing up with parents who experienced childhood trauma often face similar struggles themselves [7].
Family patterns play a huge role too. How parents and children talk to each other, handle conflict, and express emotions all shape whether trauma continues or begins to heal [5]. Sometimes families develop habits of not talking about feelings, avoiding difficult conversations, or suppressing emotions as a way to cope [4].
Cultural dissonance and identity struggles
Conflicting values between home and society
Picture this: you're sitting at the dinner table, and your parents are talking about respect, family duty, and staying close to home. Then you walk into your classroom the next day, where teachers encourage you to speak up, challenge ideas, and dream about moving across the country for college. This back-and-forth feeling is something almost every second generation immigrant knows deeply. Experts call this intergenerational cultural dissonance, and it's so common that it's considered a normal part of growing up in immigrant families [7]. The tension tends to feel even stronger for those of us from non-Western backgrounds, where the differences from mainstream American culture can feel like vast canyons [7].
Our homes often centered around family-first values, traditional expectations about how boys and girls should behave, and stricter rules that felt worlds apart from the independence and self-expression we saw celebrated around us [8]. Many of us remember watching TV shows where kids talked openly with their parents about feelings, where family disagreements got worked through with long conversations, where discipline looked completely different from what we knew [9]. It wasn't that either way was wrong—they were just so different that it sometimes felt like living in two separate realities.
Feeling like an outsider in both cultures
The hardest part might be never feeling like you fully belong anywhere. When researchers asked second generation immigrants about this, 74% said they felt like outsiders in their own culture [10]. It's a double-edged loneliness—sometimes people from our parents' homeland see us as "westernised or white-washed," while White Americans and Canadians might always see us as somehow foreign [10].
One person described growing up feeling "culturally unmoored," like being "not quite a native speaker" of either culture [11]. Another shared memories of feeling "different from classmates from the first day of school" and facing teasing because of those differences [11]. Over time, many of us learned to "code-switch"—basically becoming different versions of ourselves depending on whether we were at home or out in the world [1]. It's exhausting, but it became second nature.
The impact on second generation immigrant identity
These constant shifts between worlds shape who we become in profound ways. When you're always choosing between competing sets of values, making decisions about your life can feel incredibly complicated [8]. Most of us find our way through this without major problems, but the stress is real—research shows that the conflicts between parents and children over cultural differences can affect how we handle relationships and emotions well into our adult years [7].
What many of us eventually discover is that we don't have to choose just one side. There's something called selective acculturation—basically, taking what feels meaningful from our heritage while embracing parts of American culture that resonate with us [12]. This means honoring our families' experiences and expectations while also making space for our own values and dreams [12]. The beautiful truth is that not fully belonging to either culture doesn't mean we have to pick one and abandon the other [10]. We can create our own unique blend of both worlds.
The burden of unspoken guilt
There's a weight we carry that's hard to put into words—a mix of love and obligation that follows us through every decision we make. This isn't just about feeling bad sometimes. It's a deep psychological reality that touches our mental health, our relationships, and how we see ourselves.
How guilt forms in second generation immigrant children
The story starts the same way for so many of us: our parents sacrificed everything for us. From the time we could understand words, we heard about what our families gave up—good jobs, close friends, lives that made sense—all so we could have something better. When you grow up in an immigrant home, you learn early that your success isn't just about you. It's proof that all those sacrifices meant something [13]. The responsibility feels enormous, even when you're just a child.
What makes this harder is that kids naturally think everything is their fault [5]. When you add the knowledge that your parents came here specifically to "give you a better life," that feeling gets so much stronger [4]. We watched our parents struggle and somehow convinced ourselves we weren't doing enough to help, that maybe we were the problem [4].
Why success can feel like betrayal
Here's something that might surprise people: achieving the very things our parents wanted for us can bring up really complicated feelings. When we create lives that feel safer, happier, or just more true to who we are, it can trigger what therapists call "thriver's guilt"—the discomfort of having opportunities our parents never had [14].
This gets especially painful when we make choices our parents don't understand. Maybe we choose art over medicine, or we start setting boundaries with family, or we go to therapy. These healthy decisions can feel like we're letting everyone down [13]. When people we love are still struggling while we're doing well, success can feel wrong somehow—like we're leaving them behind [15].
Signs of internalized guilt in adulthood
This guilt doesn't just disappear when we grow up. It shows up in ways we might not even notice at first. Many of us minimize our own problems because we think we "don't have the right to complain" when "our parents had it so much worse" [13]. We do this automatically, without even realizing we're dismissing our own very real struggles [16].
The guilt affects how we take care of ourselves too. We work too much, feel bad about resting, and struggle to enjoy good things in our lives [5]. Even when we're successful, we feel like we don't deserve it [5]. Money can be especially complicated—we might have trouble spending on ourselves or feel anxious about finances even when we're doing okay [17].
Maybe the hardest part is saying no to people. We end up saying yes when we really mean no because disappointing someone feels unbearable [17]. We put everyone else's needs first, and our own wellbeing comes last. It's the same guilt we learned as children, still running our adult lives. Self-care can be tough when facing guilt, but there are ways we can help ourselves heal.
Family dynamics and emotional suppression
Trauma in immigrant families often hides in the everyday moments—the conversations that don't happen, the feelings that get pushed down, the ways we learn to survive that sometimes keep us from truly living.
How immigrant parents cope with trauma
Our parents found ways to keep going that made sense for everything they'd been through. After facing displacement, discrimination, and the exhausting work of starting over in a place that didn't always welcome them, they developed strategies that helped them survive. Research shows that for many immigrant families, stress management involves drawing on cultural resources that both protect against hardship and sometimes create new challenges [18]. What this looks like day-to-day is parents who learned to stay strong no matter what, who focus on keeping the family together rather than processing their own pain.
The silence around emotions and mental health
Maybe the hardest part for many of us has been growing up in homes where feelings weren't really talked about. In many Asian American and Canadian immigrant families, values like maintaining harmony and saving face can leave little space for being vulnerable [19]. When anger or sadness felt too dangerous to express, we learned that some parts of ourselves needed to stay hidden. Studies show this pattern over and over—families where communication stays indirect, where showing emotion feels risky, where cultural expectations of respect mean our inner world stays quiet [6].
Parenting styles shaped by survival
The way our parents raised us often reflected their deep fear that the world would be harsh to us too. Research tells us that immigrant parents often parent in ways that emphasize discipline and achievement while discouraging emotional expression [20]. We want to be clear: this came from love and worry, not from lack of caring. But it created homes where our emotional needs sometimes got overlooked. Many of us, especially oldest children, ended up taking care of things we shouldn't have had to—watching siblings, managing household tasks, even handling family problems because our parents were working so hard to build stability [20]. We became little adults, taking on emotional burdens and learning to put everyone else's needs before our own.
Parentification and emotional role reversal
The roles within immigrant families often shift in ways that can feel overwhelming, creating patterns that stay with us as second generation immigrants long into adulthood.
What is parentification?
Parentification happens when children take on adult responsibilities, either by handling practical tasks or providing emotional support for their parents [21]. There are two main ways this shows up: instrumental parentification (taking care of physical needs) and emotional parentification (meeting the psychological needs of family members) [22]. What's heartbreaking is that research shows higher levels of both forms among immigrant adolescents compared to kids from families who were born here [21].
How immigrant children become caregivers
The reason this happens so often comes down to something called the acculturation gap [22]. As second generation immigrants, we usually adapt to American culture faster than our parents, which puts us in the position of becoming bridges between two worlds [2]. So many of us became "cultural brokers" early on—translating letters, helping navigate doctor visits, managing family finances—long before we were ready for that kind of responsibility [2]. This isn't something we chose; it often happened because our families needed us to step up in ways that most kids our age didn't have to [21].
Long-term effects on self-worth and boundaries
The effects of taking on these roles are complicated. On one hand, instrumental parentification predicts positive outcomes like building confidence and capability in both immigrant and non-immigrant teens [21]. But for those of us who grew up this way, it also often leads to feeling exhausted and burned out [21]. Many of us developed deep empathy and strength, but we also struggle with knowing where our responsibilities end and others' begin [22]. Even as adults, we might find ourselves feeling responsible for everyone else's happiness while neglecting our own needs [2]. Constantly balancing cultural expectations with caregiving roles can leave us feeling confused about who we really are and never quite good enough—feelings that can last well into our adult lives [23].
Breaking the trauma cycle: Steps toward healing
The path to healing starts with one important truth: none of this is your fault [24]. You didn't create these wounds, but you do have the power to heal them. That's both a gift and a responsibility we carry as second generation immigrants.
Grieving the family you never had
This might feel strange at first, but healing often begins with grief. We need to acknowledge what we missed growing up—maybe it was emotional safety, feeling truly seen, or simply having our feelings matter [25]. This isn't about pointing fingers at our parents. It's about being honest with ourselves.
You can feel grateful for your parents' sacrifices and still grieve what you needed but didn't receive. Both feelings can exist at the same time [25]. Your parents did the best they could with what they had, and you still deserved more emotional support than you got.
Setting healthy boundaries with immigrant parents
The word "boundaries" might feel uncomfortable in families that taught us to put everyone else first. But here's something important: good boundaries actually make relationships stronger, not weaker. They prevent resentment from building up and creating distance between you and your family [3].
When you're ready to try setting boundaries:
Start small—maybe ending a phone call when you're too tired to talk
Speak with kindness that honors their sacrifices
Use "I" statements like: "When I hear your voice get louder, it gets hard for me to talk to you because I get scared" [26]
Learn to overcome emotional suppression:
Recognize that emotional suppression can manifest in various ways, such as avoiding difficult conversations or dismissing your own feelings. Acknowledge these patterns and gently challenge them by expressing your emotions in safe spaces, with trusted friends, journaling, or using an outlet such as movement, music or art. Over time, this practice can help you cultivate a deeper understanding of your needs and foster healthier connections with your family.
Reclaiming your identity and voice
Healing means deciding which parts of your culture feel right for you and which parts don't serve you anymore. You get to choose what traditions to keep and what new paths to create [24]. This isn't about rejecting your heritage—it's about honoring it in a way that feels authentic to who you are.
Conclusion
We've discussed how pain can travel through families unintentionally, how growing up between cultures can make us feel out of place, and how unspoken guilt shapes our choices. We've examined how silence around emotions became a family language and how many learned to care for others before themselves.
The guilt whispering you don't deserve good things? It can go. The feeling of betraying your family by choosing your path? That can soften. The exhaustion from carrying others' emotions? You can learn to set that down. Yes, healing takes time. It requires gratitude for our parents' sacrifices while mourning what we lacked. It means setting boundaries that may feel scary but bring us closer to loved ones. It's about choosing which parts of our heritage resonate with us, rather than carrying traditions that no longer serve us. Most importantly, healing asks us to be gentle—with our ancestors who survived unimaginable hardships, with our parents who did their best, and especially with ourselves.
When we heal, we change our lives and create a different future for the next generation. Your experience as a second-generation immigrant has given you a precious ability: to bridge worlds, understand diverse perspectives, and carry both strength and tenderness. These are gifts, not burdens. The path forward isn't easy, but you don't have to walk it alone. There are others who understand, therapists who get it, and communities where your story resonates. Your healing matters, and it's already begun.
Key Takeaways
Second generation immigrants face unique psychological challenges that stem from inherited trauma, cultural conflicts, and family dynamics. Understanding these patterns is the first step toward healing and breaking cycles that have persisted across generations.
• Intergenerational trauma passes through biological and behavioral mechanisms - Children inherit psychological wounds through epigenetic changes and family dynamics, even without experiencing the original trauma themselves.
• Cultural dissonance creates persistent identity struggles - Feeling caught between two worlds leads to not fully belonging anywhere, requiring navigation of conflicting values between home and mainstream society.
• Unspoken guilt manifests as difficulty with self-care and boundaries - Success can feel like betrayal, leading to overwork, imposter syndrome, and reluctance to prioritize personal needs over family obligations.
• Parentification forces children into adult roles prematurely - Acting as cultural brokers and emotional caregivers builds resilience but often comes at the cost of childhood development and healthy boundary formation.
• Healing requires grieving, boundaries, emotional regulation, and culturally-informed support - Breaking the trauma cycle involves mourning what was missing, setting healthy limits with family, and seeking therapy that understands immigrant experiences.
The journey toward healing isn't about blame—it's about acknowledging inherited patterns while taking responsibility for creating healthier foundations for ourselves and future generations.
We are here for you
When we heal, we change our lives and create a different future for the next generation. Your experience as a second-generation immigrant has given you a precious ability: to bridge worlds, understand diverse perspectives, and carry both strength and tenderness. These are gifts, not burdens. The path forward isn't easy, but you don't have to walk it alone. There are others who understand, therapists who get it, and communities where your story resonates. Your healing matters, and it's already begun.
Reach out today for a free 15 minute consultation to speak to one of our trauma informed therapists, Celeste Cai, or Sho Sho O, or email us at info@restingtree.ca and discover how we can walk alongside you. Your story matters to us, and we're here to help you write its next chapter.
References
[1] - https://eggshelltherapy.com/second-generation-immigrant/
[2] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12220155/
[3] - https://www.psychologytoday.com/ca/blog/the-basics-of-childrens-mental-health/202407/intergenerational-trauma-in-immigrant-families
[4] - https://imilo.medium.com/between-two-worlds-8-challenges-as-a-second-generation-immigrants-4fe556e48fa7
[5] - https://egrove.olemiss.edu/etd/469/
[6] - https://www.psychologytoday.com/ca/basics/intergenerational-trauma
[7] - https://www.networkforphl.org/news-insights/healing-across-generations-addressing-the-impact-of-intergenerational-trauma-through-policy-interventions/
[8] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6127768/
[9] - https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20190326-what-is-epigenetics
[10] - https://arkansasadvocate.com/2023/07/05/understanding-epigenetics-how-trauma-is-passed-on-through-our-family-members/
[11] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5362358/
[12] - https://www.drdavidappelbaum.com/the-echo-of-trauma-understanding-generational-impact-in-immigrant-families/
[13] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2475652/
[14] - https://www.definingmomentsca.com/blog/culture-and-identity/reconciling-cultural-difference-with-immigrant-parents
[15] - https://thewildcattribune.com/15005/opinion/feeling-like-a-cultural-outsider-three-perspectives/
[16] - https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/04/learning/have-you-ever-felt-like-an-outsider.html
[17] - https://folioweekly.com/2024/07/24/navigating-bi-cultural-identity-as-a-child-of-immigrants/
[18] - https://ojs.library.ubc.ca/index.php/cjur/article/view/195268
[19] - https://optimumjoy.com/blog/mental-health-in-bicultural-immigrant-families/
[20] - https://www.psychologytoday.com/ca/blog/living-with-emotional-intensity/202301/8-challenges-of-growing-up-as-a-second-generation
[21] - https://www.washingtonpost.com/wellness/2024/05/04/guilt-second-generation-immigrants-coping-strategies/
[22] - https://www.miptherapy.com/blog/thriving-abroad-understanding-immigrant-guilt-and-emotional-complexity
[23] - https://www.cnn.com/2022/10/26/health/mental-health-children-of-immigrants-wellness
[24] - https://www.shebelongsherenow.com/blog/immigrant-guilt
[25] - https://www.psychologytoday.com/ca/blog/empowering-children-of-immigrants/202509/how-culture-shapes-the-way-families-cope-with-stress
[26] - https://pacificpath.ca/recognizing-and-addressing-emotional-suppression/
[27] - https://journals.kmanpub.com/index.php/aftj/article/view/3960
[28] - https://behavioralhealthnews.org/the-burden-of-being-the-good-child-how-south-asian-kids-suppress-mental-health-struggles/
[29] - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21879381/
[30] - https://coldteacollective.com/parentification-of-immigrant-children-how-i-became-my-familys-translator-and-emotional-support-system/
[31] - https://www.liberationhealingseattle.com/blog-trauma-therapist/parentification-trauma-among-asian-immigrants-and-their-children
[32] - https://www.atlas-therapy.care/blog-posts/adult-children-of-immigrants
[33] - https://newmoonpsychotherapy.ca/understanding-intergenerational-trauma-in-south-asian-immigrant-families/
[34] - https://www.noortherapyandwellness.com/blog/the-grief-we-dont-name-diasporic-grief-8nat7
[35] - https://thebadindiantherapist.com/san-francisco-blog/how-to-set-boundaries-with-immigrant-parents
[36] - https://www.psychologytoday.com/ca/blog/immigrant-stories/202307/how-to-set-boundaries-with-immigrant-parents
[37] - https://www.daniellecounselling.com/blog/healing-for-second-generation-canadians-and-their-families
[38] - https://www.peacheycounselling.ca/blog/2024/what-is-intergenerational-trauma-can-it-be-healed